Skip Navigation

InitialsDiceBearhttps://github.com/dicebear/dicebearhttps://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/„Initials” (https://github.com/dicebear/dicebear) by „DiceBear”, licensed under „CC0 1.0” (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/)NO
Posts
0
Comments
635
Joined
2 yr. ago

  • Yes, it’s science fantasy. I mean that’s what I also meant by sci fi and fantasy being under the same category in many countries and languages.

    Sci fi is not about scientific accuracy. It was born in the time of scientificism, of science as a mystical force almost. Sci fi is more about space lasers and robots than science.

    Hard sci fi that actually takes science into account is a later development.

    Star Wars is closer to the “traditional” sci fi ideas than hard sci fi. And that’s the only thing I was saying.

  • Don’t you think saying “they can go FTL by building engines that go FTL” is not very scientific?

    That isn’t an actual scientific explanation.

    But that’s not the point of Star Wars. Sure a lot of stuff that is now Legenda did try to make a bit more sense of things. But never too much, because it would take away the magic of it.

    It feels like a medieval fantasy world of knights, dark wizards (and racism I guess), but in space. Too much science would lose the fairy tale vibes.

    It’s like expecting Dune to explain the physics behind the “Voice”. Dune is supposed to be this incomprehensible and distant tale, like reading from the first papyri from Egypt. It’s supposed to be mysterious and familiar but alien. Diving into the “science” of things in the way we understand science would kill the vibe.

  • I guess, but being a soldier is hardly a position of power is it? Are people attracted to the military because of authority?

    I never felt soldiers had any authority over me or anything lol

    If a soldier told me to do something, I’d just laugh. Even a general or something like that tbh.

    Do “civilian” people generally feel the military has any authority over them/non-military things?

  • Space opera is sci fi.

    As a note… in many countries and languages there is no distinction between fantasy and sci fi. Sci fi is just modernist, scientificism inspired fantasy. Eventually hard sci fi came to be, and overtook most of the genre, but there are no requirements for sci fi to “make scientific sense”. It just has to have space, robots, lasers etc.

    I mean, if you go by how the genre was born and all.

  • The technology isn’t presented as magical..?

    Kyber crystal? Hyper lanes? FTL? THE FORCE? Star Wars is sci-fi in flavouring only. There’s no sci in that fi at all. And that’s ok, that’s not the point of the stories.

  • Issue with Tacitus is he wrote about Jesus over 70 years after he allegedly died. After a Christian movement was already under way.

    And yes I do think Jesus was a real historical figure.

    But we have very little actual history on him, that’s all.

  • Sadly there are not a lot of extra-biblical sources on Jesus and his life actually.

    There is one, a single one. And it’s pretty bad. Josephus. He basically mentions “James, the brother of Jesus they call Christ”, in the middle of a text not about Jesus at all.

    And that’s it.

  • Ah so thinking about solutions, very doable solutions mind you, is nonsense. It’s like teleportation, which is physically impossible. While making payments to developing countries to keep their nature intact is perfectly possible in many many ways.

    But yeah, let’s all completely stop deforesting. That’s much more plausible.

  • I don’t want to say where I’m from, but I am very familiar with Brazilian politics so it shouldn’t matter.

    None of those policies are communist. Communism is a future state of society after socialism, where there is no state, money or classes.

    Those are social-democratic policies. Like there were in the US and Europe after WW2 up until the age of neoliberalism in the 70s-80s.

    They are better than neoliberalism, don’t get me wrong. I much prefer Lula than a neoliberal like Temer or a fascist like Bolsonaro.

    But that doesn’t change that Lula is a neoliberal, with some social-democratic policies.

    It’s not entirely his fault (even though other politicians like Dilma are less neolib brained than Lula…) as Brazil is, like most other places in this planet, a province of the US Empire.

    It’s an exploitation province, built to extract wealth into the central provinces. The elites that exist exist because they perpetuate this system. They benefit a little, but comparatively to the misery of the masses, they live as kings so it’s good enough for them.

    Lula can keep doing what he does if he doesn’t stop the flow of wealth to the outside. If he stops it in any way, couped again.

    We’re all second-class citizens of the Empire. Yes, even you workingperson from the US/Canada/Germany/UK etc etc.