Just remind yourself that you already did the hard work of overthinking when you started keeping a TBR list and adding books to it, and randomly choose one to start next😄
This is why I started using a booktracking app. I keep a TBR list based on books I've heard about/seem interesting to me. I alternate between fiction and non-fiction and only read books on my TBR, and solved the issue of choosing the next book.
I notice that I tend to read more when I engage with the app. I was thinking of switching to something self-hosted, but meh... I like Storygraph well enough to stay there.
Developer Voices with Kris Jenkins. Great in-depth conversation with developers about a new and interesting project they're working on.