Two Israeli embassy staff shot dead near Washington DC Jewish museum
TranscendentalEmpire @ TranscendentalEmpire @lemm.ee Posts 0Comments 1,219Joined 2 yr. ago
TranscendentalEmpire @ TranscendentalEmpire @lemm.ee
Posts
0
Comments
1,219
Joined
2 yr. ago
Deleted
Permanently Deleted
I mean, I don't think you get to decide what the scope of the context is.
For this not to be contextual you would have to claim that the deaths of tens of thousands of civilians had nothing to do with the gunman's motive. I think that would be hard to claim considering that the murders were politically motivated, considering that the two victims were diplomats.
I think people have gotten a little too comfortable with claiming anything that shares a sentence structure with a logical fallacy to be a logical fallacy. You have to remember that logical fallacies have to be illogical in the first place. It's not illogical to assume these two claims are associated.
Whataboutism have to equivocate two different scenarios that aren't logically associated with the events in the originating claim.