Skip Navigation

InitialsDiceBearhttps://github.com/dicebear/dicebearhttps://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/„Initials” (https://github.com/dicebear/dicebear) by „DiceBear”, licensed under „CC0 1.0” (https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/)SO
Posts
31
Comments
2,294
Joined
2 yr. ago

  • Here's a 47 THOUSAND WORD NEGATIVE REVIEW railing that much about how terrible a certain Gary Stu fanfic (HPMOR) is. I mean it's insane. Not many people like HPMOR (it's aimed at a particular type of nerd) and even its admirers know it has errors and lots of cringy parts. The reviewer instead goes through the whole fic sentence by sentence finding things to complain about. Most of the complaints are correct but trivial, adding up to "so what?".

    Anyway it wouldn't occur to me that Gary Stu is automatically loved. Lots of people hate HPMOR, I mean really hate it, but most do the sensible thing and stop reading after a few chapters, or maybe even read it all and then say "wow, that sucked" and go on to something else. So there.

  • Turn it off completely. I opened a thread about it a while back when I tried to recommend WGM Jennifer Shahade's memoir "Chess Bi tch" and both the title and link got censored. I could bypass the text censorship but the link was harder. Not good. We aren't kids here and if something needs removal, leave it to human mods and reports.

  • Yes, I think as a pure theological question, historical thought has been a bit complicated. So I linked to the Wikipedia article that hopefully goes into it a bit. I admit to not having read the Wikipedia article carefully. This isn't my area at all.

  • How could a human be dumb enough to talk about the Bekenstein bound having something to do with the shape of galaxies, but them seamlessly go from there to talking about the shape of flowers? Flowers have nothing to do with the Bekenstein bound. Of course it's dubious even for galaxies. And anyone who has studied basic classical mechanics or ODE's knows that harmonic oscillators occur everywhere in nature. Unforced ones give circular or elliptical orbits, and forced ones (meaning the eigenvalue is not purely imaginary) give spirals, inward or outward depending on the sign of the real part.

    Human or ChatGPT, meh, maybe you are right that it was written by a human, at least partly. But I've seen flowery though meaningless language come out of ChatGPT before.

    Anyway, it's crap.