Skip Navigation

User banner
Posts
5
Comments
131
Joined
4 yr. ago

  • I think you're wrong actually. The map in question does not seem to use the ISW data.

    This is the point you are referring to from ISW: https://understandingwar.org/backgrounder/russian-offensive-campaign-assessment-july-23-2023

    (Aside, According to this arcticle, your 54% is not an actual hard percentage, but an estimate. From their own words, they measure the area of the map using Mercator projection, and state using a different projection would give you a different estimate. They don't correct for projection error in their measurement, which as I pointed out earlier, biases the figure towards overestimating the recaptured territory in the north, and underestimating the area still under Russia's control in the south. )

    But compare LiveUA map to the timelapse here. Their data shows large areas under Russian control that are not shown as recaptured on the LiveUA map. I should not have said "looks like" when it is clear from the map that the red area, minus Crimea and pre-2022 DPR and LPR, is still much larger than the blue area.

    Saying 50% has been recaptured is contingent upon how much territory Russia actually controlled in the Kharkiv and Kiev areas during the first few weeks of the war. This figure is insanely variable based on who you ask. In those first few weeks, Russian propagandists would greatly overstate how much territory in the north had been captured. In reality, Russia went into the northern area with a very small force and captured a few highways. If you paint with a very broad brush, all of the surrounding area came under Russian control, even if Russian troops never had a presence there. But that does not correspond to the strict reality.

  • "Map projections" lmao. The mercator map makes area look bigger the further north it is. So if anything, it would oversize the area that Ukraine has retaken in the north while undersizing the area that Russia has taken in the south. But within a small country, distortion from map projection will be negligible.

  • Not to mention it's always attributed to Albert Einstein which is not something he said and not something he would ever have said. Doesn't stop people from continuing to invoke this "definition of insanity" as if its a smart thing to say.

  • Blinken makes no distinction between what territory changed hands before 2022 and after. That wasn't the claim

    Edit: Even so, the red area that is not outlined still looks bigger than the blue areas.

  • So he's trying to argue the blue area = the red area in size. Doesn't look exactly so.

  • I heard one once that goes like "a fool does what he hates, a wise man does what he loves, but a great man learns to love what is necessary."
    I think I am butchering the original phrasing which is probably why I can't find any source for this quote. But I think about it a lot.

  • I posted this on 2022 new years. But what's your July resolution?

  • It would be equally as easy to lie either way. Instead of reporting 1000 anonymous upvotes, report 1000 fake upvotes from fake users or users who didn't actually upvote. Any instance that gets caught abusing the protocol would get blocked pretty quickly though. Even though it's theoretically possible, I've never seen it happen.

  • When you win at chair solitaire

  • You are either camping with other people or are in some kind of military activity. You don't want to poop because you are embarrassed of how it smells and the people you were with on a previous occasion gave you an extremely hard time over it. Did I guess right? Please, poop in a hole or something, whatever it takes

  • This is a legit observation. However, I would argue that spaces needs a set indentation width anyway, so if tabs had a set indentation width that coders are expected to maintain when aligning code, it wouldn't make a difference. Enforcing that in practice may be different, but in theory it works.

  • I wonder if they include Biden's bombing of Nord Stream

  • Rip people born in 1988

  • You will own nothing and you will be happy -Netflix

  • I deleted my Reddit almost 2 years ago. I can say I am a much happier person since.

  • "It's not about Putin, it's about Russia" is a true statement. History is not decided by great men. History is decided by the class struggle and material conditions. And right now, Russia is in a popular front just like China was in WW2. Why? Because the west wants to open up Russia's economy to foreign interests. They want to privatize Russia's state oil and gas firms and expropriate the profits. The same thing they have done for the resources of countries all over the world. Proof? You can see it in public. Leaders and pundits in NATO are already floating around the idea of regime change in Russia. They are going to try to start a coup and put in a US friendly leader in Russia.

    @sexy_peach@feddit.de since you were asking too

  • No it's just a realist view. Great man theory was completely discredited by modern political economy. Read a book.

  • Someone downvoted a comment I had literally 2 secs after I posted it. They wouldn't have had time to read anything I wrote or the source I linked. They're seething at anyone who thinks outside the NATO box.