galloog1 @ galloog1 @lemmy.world

Posts

0

Comments

474

Joined

2 yr. ago

Go for it. If it is so easy you are welcome to go put yourself in harm's way. Don't criticize when you have not been faced with the decisions and a lack of full awareness. Hamas is not sitting out in the middle of a field waiting to be struck.

Okay genius, how do you kill them when they are in tunnels under neighborhoods? You cannot get into them without an explosion, even if present in person and they won't just sit there either. This is not a war crime and I'm really questioning everyone's collective intelligence and ability to think through problems instead of reacting to stimulus.

Yes, war in an urban environment is bad. This is why it took a literal terrorist attack to prompt Israel to do it. There's nothing that could be done to simultaneously win the war and prevent civilian casualties of this magnitude. I am a literal military strategist and there is no way possible considering the tunnel systems.

The news media made the same claims against the US concerning white phosphorous and that was not true so my burden of proof concerning white phosphorous is so high it actually supports the opposing narrative without some damn good evidence.

... According to Hamas which has demonstrated with evidence that they lie in almost every instance to get ahead of the narrative. So far there has been no evidence that any Israeli organizational narrative has been false.

Hamas is literally in this video firing missiles. The people on this site including yourself have your heads in the sand.

Nothing builds a coalition as effectively as insisting that you absolutely must include a controversial but completely unrelated topic in the effort.

To take out Hamas using any other approach than the way Israel is currently doing it would be much worse for civilians. I'm not the original commentator but don't get me wrong, you do not understand war. You do not understand war crimes. You do not understand the difference between them.

We're mad at all the propaganda blaming Israel for decisions not made in a fucking vacuum.

Doing nothing has progressively made the situation worse over the past 17 years every time. Limited engagements have lost them the information war and produced severe international backlash and still not eliminated Hamas. Large scale combat operations were always going to be this bad on civilians. It always is. This isn't counter insurgency. They are fighting a full on war and it took a massively resourced and foreign supported terrorist attack on civilians to get them to commit to it.

They did. Israel is firing at Hamas, not hospitals. Full stop.

To take out Hamas any other way would be worse for civilians because it would involve a longer operation including a cordon. Look at 2017 in Mosul if you don't believe me.

If you were an army officer you would understand how funny this is.

This post is somehow managing to offend on a personal level almost everyone.

Literally held a session with Captains and Majors yesterday. It involved a wet gap crossing.

That's the problem with generalizing the United States. Every state has a different approach to the problem.

You can highly doubt all you want but go do some research on current consumer behavior after you are done doubting.

That is how Hamas frames it. I wouldn't consider it convenient from Israel's pov.

You are welcome to blame colonial powers for setting up this situation from the remains of the Ottoman Empire but it is also worth going into why Israelis have been driven out of the rest of the world into Israel and the multiple wars conducted against them by powers claiming they have no right to exist. Those same claims are continued by Hamas and Iran and used to justify starting this current war. The same borders that instituted Israel also initially instituted Palestine until they conducted a war against them. That war was what caused these borders at question with the refugee camp.

It absolutely is worth looking into the history behind it.

Your comment does not address the fact that the above was disinformation. Not misinformation, but disinformation as it is intentionally misleading.

The refuge camp you refer to was created in 1948. It no longer functions as a refugee camp. You are a disinformer.

I've noticed. The sheer volume this account posts is enough to give the appearance of a consensus.

I'll ask again. Stop ignoring it and answer the question. What do you consider moral in war? I need to get you to be able to understand the difference between war and war crimes when it comes to morals. I will not allow you to continue to bounce around the topic.