What SF books did you enjoy the most in 2024?
Deleted
Permanently Deleted
Deleted
Permanently Deleted
Deleted
Permanently Deleted
Deleted
Permanently Deleted
Deleted
Permanently Deleted
Deleted
Permanently Deleted
While Cixian Liu coined the words "dark forest" to describe this particular solution to the fermi paradox, he did not invent it.
Having also read the series, I find myself always having to mention that while the books do some of the best exploration of more complex sci-fi concepts, they are WEIRD about gender.
The whole thing with men becoming "feminized" by an age of peace, reeks. The author goes out of his way to equate competence, decisiveness and conviction with the male gender, and tries to very akwardly make the point that without strife, these things become unnecessary, and even abhorred. To the point that "masculinity" as a social construct disappears from society. Then replaced entirely by "femininity" which the author VERY explicitly equates with "beauty", naivete, indecision and weakness.
As if women choose to be with men only out of necessity, and if given a easy life and therefore the choice, they would pair off with other women. Which is effectively what happens because according to the author such a society would pressure men into becoming indistinguishable from women in order to remain appealing.
If I had to boil the trilogy down to a message about gender, it would be "men are ugly but useful, women are beautiful but useless". That's not exactly progressive...
A major female characters entire character is that she is the "perfect" woman, and she is literally given as payment to the main-character, by the government. And no-one in the story bats an eye at this! Including the woman herself!
I kept expecting her to be disingenuous. You know, because she was literally treated like an object, given as a prize. But then it time-skips to her having the dudes kid! So apparently shes's fine with it?
Execept then when the government says so, she's perfectly down with up and leaving the guy, this time to force him into action by withholding her. Again she's a mere plot device, treated like a thing that can not only be given, by also taken. She barely exists as anything more than the concept "perfect woman". But you can't just have a human character without there being a person in there. Yet Liu goes ahead anyway.
The subtext about gender in the writing isn't subtle, and it really fucking bothered me when reading the series. I tuned out a lot when listening to the audiobooks.
The sci-fi concepts are some of the best! Only one example is the way the books explained FTL travel, and it is some of the most compelling I've seen!
But I really can't imagine recommending the series without a disclaimer about it containing some of the most sexist writing I've ever come across.