LukeZaz @ LukeZaz @beehaw.org

Posts

6

Comments

234

Joined

1 yr. ago

It is, but DdCno1's been taking a pro-Israel stance into a very, very pro-Palestine site. I really don't know what else they'd expect besides pushback, honestly.

Why do you think voting is your only option?

It goes to show how I can say something so patently and obviously untrue and sarcastic and yet it still doesn't register as such. America has developed such a hyper-focus on voting to the exclusion of all other possibilities that it's basically learned helplessness at this point.

So you believe that erstwhile hostage rescuers have no responsibility to actually keep the hostages alive, then? Because you're writing apologia for that.

a ruthless movement that would rather sacrifice every single Palestinian man, woman and child than surrender

You know, I've no love for Hamas whatsoever, but I can't help but notice you consider "willingness to sacrifice civilians" to be somehow worse than, say, "actually, literally sacrificing civilians right now." That's not a very good look.

with the ICC waiting with handcuffs behind the banner

This implies other countries wouldn't sooner dismantle the ICC than let it actually do its job, which sadly seems to not be the case.

^{(edit: typo)}

How would abstaining or voting for Trump help the situation in Gaza at all?

Why do you think these are the only options?

As we all know, politics is a dichotomy!

you’re watching us hula hoop the ourobouros.

I am absolutely loving this bit. Very strong phrase, and as a bonus, excellent mental imagery!

This is why I think monitored access is a better idea than total withholding. Kids are going to end up on social media; either as they grow up and eventually become adults, or as a result of peer providing access & pressure. Best to let them on, but ensure they are safe, know how to be safe, and know why to be safe.

Makes me wonder if it’s intentional to try to make society a worse place with inventive uses of pushing certain trends on international versions of tiktok instead of filtering them out.

Good lord, this is a massive reach. A much simpler explanation is that algorithmic garbage is profitable, and China's government does not care about negative ramifications that occur outside China itself and so do not regulate it.

China's run by a terrible government, not an MCU villain.

Can we pack the court yet?

On the presidential ticket for 2024, yes, harm reduction is the only option. But I don't have to like it, and it's not gonna mean that I'm not going to criticize and protest the genocide she enables.

There's more to politics than just voting in an undemocratic system.

The whole “genocide joe” narrative did not provide any benefit in Gaza,

Biden's admin absolutely noticed the protests against him and it was because of that that we got a pause (however temporary) on some of the heavy ordnance sold to Israel. The uncommitted votes in the primaries did not go unnoticed either. Not to mention that absolutely none of us are suggesting Trump is a viable alternative to anyone (i.e. we are not discouraging voting against him), and that we'd protest just as fervently (if not more) if he did win.

All this however is placing the blame on us for standing up for what we believe in, and implicitly forgiving the Biden admin for the atrocities they enable — after all, if they wanted to secure their candidacy more, why not acquiesce? Everyone's all ready to criticize the people protesting to save lives, but not so much prepared to criticize the people enabling the killing?

Still, let's be generous and take this as true regardless. Once the election is over, are you willing to commit to joining us in protesting until the U.S. stops sending weapons to Israel, regardless of who wins?

And folks wonder why I'm not optimistic for a Harris admin.

I can't understand how anyone could see a vote for her as anything other than harm reduction.

So if leftists really cared about Gaza, they'd... not protest the party currently in power? The one selling the bombs?

Because I don't think you genuinely believe any leftist, tankie or otherwise, actually likes Trump. I think you just don't like it when they protest Biden or Harris.

So people need to vehemently denounce Trump once per hour or else they must obviously be siding with him...?

Seriously though, isn't it obvious? If you expect Trump to be terrible, why would you fly into a rage when he meets that expectation? By contrast, Biden is expected to be better than this, and yet isn't.

Pressure is applied where it is most effective. That is not and will never be anyone from the Republican party, because they openly and obviously do not give a fuck about any of us.

^{(edited for kinder tone)}

Estimates of Palestinian deaths have long since exceeded tens of thousands. How you can believe that the October attacks could possibly have exceeded that is beyond me.

But you've already made up your mind. I don't even know why you're here.

stopping supporting anti hamas actions won’t stop the war… it will just lead to more innocent people dying

If you think more innocent people will die if Israel stops bombing Gaza into dust, then you haven't been paying attention to what's happening to Palestinians.

Everything Hamas has done, terrible as it is, pales in comparison to the tragedy and horror inflicted by the IDF.

but sounds like a reasonable amount for anyone except the most marginalized groups

I know several people for whom $167 per month would be a big problem. Considering how many people struggle to get by on incredibly low wages, with ever-increasing rent, I really don't think it's fair to suggest that this would only be a problem for "the most marginalized groups."

And that's all ignoring the fact that "being unable to afford medicine" is not a problem anyone in such a rich country should ever have to face, regardless of income. Frankly, I really don't care if it upends industries; people's lives are more important than that.