Communist @ communist @lemmy.frozeninferno.xyz

I'm an anarchocommunist, all states are evil.

---

Read more

Posts

1

Comments

731

Joined

1 yr. ago

It runs x11, the wayland port is going insanely slow, x11 has the following problems every time:

1. Every single app can read all of your keyboard input without asking
2. Every single app can see what every single other app is doing without asking
3. Apps can fullscreen themselves and go over everything else, because they can control their own window placement to any degree they want, again, without asking.
4. HDR https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/xorg/xserver/-/issues/1037#note_521100 (if you need a source)
5. mixed refresh rate and dpi display configurations.

It may support these someday, maybe. But progress is absurdly slow. Considering cinnamon has fewer changes as a whole than just the KDE text editor alone, kde is a significantly better choice if you want a well-supported, bug-free and feature rich experience.

Note here, a lot of people are going to recommend you mint, I honestly think mint is an outdated suggestion for beginners, I think immutability is extremely important for someone who is just starting out, as well as starting on KDE since it’s by far the most developed DE that isn’t gnome and their… design decisions are unfortunate for people coming from windows.

I don’t think we should be recommending mint to beginners anymore, if mint makes an immutable, up to date KDE distro, that’ll change, but until then, I think bazzite is objectively a better starting place for beginners.

The mere fact that bazzite and other immutables generate a new system for you on update and let you switch between and rollback automatically is enough for me to say it’s better, but it also has more up to date software, and tons of guides (fedora is one of the most popular distros, and bazzite is essentially identical except with some QoL upgrades).

How common is the story of “I was new to linux and completely broke it”? that’s not a good user experience for someone who’s just starting, it’s intimidating, scary, and I just don’t think it’s the best in the modern era. There’s something to be said about learning from these mistakes, but bazzite essentially makes these mistakes impossible.

Furthermore because of the way bazzite works, package management is completely graphical and requires essentially no intervention on the users part, flathub and immutability pair excellently for this reason.

Cinnamon (the default mint environment) doesn’t and won’t support HDR, the security/performance improvements from wayland, mixed refresh rate displays, mixed DPI displays, fractional scaling, and many other things for a very very long time if at all. I don’t understand the usecase for cinnamon tbh, xfce is great if you need performance but don’t want to make major sacrifices, lxqt is great if you need A LOT of performance, cinnamon isn’t particularly performant and just a strictly worse version of kde in my eyes from the perspective of a beginner, anyway.

I have 15 years of linux experience and am willing to infinitely troubleshoot if you add me on matrix.

Yeah hook me up with their number I'll do it

Element x is pretty solid but not perfect, matrix-rust-sdk needs to have desktop clients, servers need to support all the new stuff, I give element 5 years before it's a top tier messenger

Exactly what I was here to write, had so much fun with that

...but dolphins don't all speak the same language?

I used mine all the time because I hate using bluetooth even though I have expensive bluetooth headphones, I have now cancelled you out

How?

https://element.io/

it's essentially a federated messenger, just like lemmy is a federated reddit.

It's likely you can get that proprietary software working, if you want to try.

My username is on my profile!

Honestly, your usage of linux since 1999 is why I don't trust you know what's best for beginners. I give tons of people linux, mostly the elderly, cinnamon has been an absolutely terrible experience for them. You're highly experienced and used to something that works for you, the best choice for beginners changes more than you do.

but what it does, it does well.

Can you not say this about fedora/bazzite?

The same can not be said about other distros in conjunction to care-free users.

The very purpose of an immutable distro is to stop carefree users from doing exactly that, until mint makes an immutable distro, it simply isn't the best choice for beginners.

Do they not care about mixed refresh rate displays, mixed dpi displays, the security issues involved in x11, etc? I think they will prefer if those things just work. Mint doesn't have that, sure what works works well, but that's true for fedora/bazzite too... and more works.

i don’t trust them either but from what i have seen most don’t care

They get this benefit for free on KDE. Even if they don't care, it's still better for them.

this is a bit of a stretch

I don't see how it's a stretch, someone was posting with basically this exact problem on one of the linux forums on lemmy like, last week. I don't feel like digging up the post but this happens sometimes.

i don’t agree on everything and maybe you’re right i still don’t get why they dropped support for kde but still support MATE

Makes absolutely no sense for a beginner distro.

but i don’t think that this is a big problem for most for now since our user base is small so there is much less malware and targeted attacks (well as long as you are not a high profile employee at a company with vast data access privileges )

Security is not as huge of a problem on linux as it is on windows for sure. But EVERY SINGLE proprietary app you use can snoop on EVERYTHING. and I do not trust proprietary apps, beginners especially will use a ton of proprietary software. Remember that we're recommending to a beginner, not a linux evangelist who is willing to do anything to make linux/foss work for them.

i don’t understand what you mean exactly by performance when talking about a DE ( responsiveness, ram and cpu usage ? …). in terms of cpu and ram usage i’m pretty sure that kde consumes more and in terms responsiveness i would assume that kde is better but how much ( a difference between 5 s and 2 s is huge but from let’s say 80 nanosecond to 60 is just for benchmarks and won’t be noticed in real world usage)

If you use KDE on a laptop from like 2002 it will be a HORRIBLE experience, they use way too much ram, way too much rendering (with animations and whatnot), absolute cpu and gpu hogs for a machine from back then. that's pretty much the reason xfce and lxde exist. It'll also be real bad on cinnamon. Maybe this is better now, I haven't tried in a while.

The only reason I see for a beginner not to choose KDE over xfce is if they have a laptop from the 32 bit era. Elsewise, KDE if you use windows, Gnome if you use macos. The development speed alone and the fact that they have proper funding means in 20 years they'll probably still be around, cinnamon development is nearly dead by comparison, we shouldn't be encouraging people to use significantly less supported software unless there's a compelling reason, and for cinnamon, there really just isn't. People won't want to relearn everything when cinnamon breaks for them, might as well start on the most well supported stuff for all hardware.

I personally don't use KDE, but I don't think we should be recommending anything but KDE/Gnome to beginners without very good reason. Sure, use whatever you want, but that isn't a valid course of action for someone who doesn't even know where to start, and the obvious answer for where to start is KDE.

I think many people here have been linux users for so long that they forget their solution isn't the best choice for beginners.