The most hated science fiction writer (It's not Heinlein, Hubbard, OR Andy Weir)
The most hated science fiction writer (It's not Heinlein, Hubbard, OR Andy Weir)
27 comments
-
-
I recently learned about Orson Scott Cards history, and his article "The Hypocrites of Homosexuality" that he wrote for the Mormon church.
So we can add that to our list.
-
Andy weir? Why? Who would hate him and why?
-
Putting Weir in that list rather than Card or Ringo is an odd choice.
-
Personally, I think Yellow Submarine is a timeless classic. 🤷🏼♂️
-
-
Hubbard has gotta be up there, though!
Heinlein is great, leave him alone.
-
Heinlen is a pompous twat that preaches his off-brand ayn rand ripoff philosiphy through shallow mary sue self-inserts that are never wrong, tell it how it is and are also perfectly competent, virile, have huge dicks and are somehow the most eminent philosiphers of their time. . His prose is juvenile, clunky, and artless . His characters are shallow and one dimensional. Worst of all, he just never stops ranting and preaching about the evils of communism.
It's cold war era slop by mediocre propagandist who somehow became convinced of his own greatness.
-
Helinlein stayed in the navy long enough to pick up all their authoritarian traditions and buy into them full throatedly, but not long enough to go into combat and see them all falling apart and gain some wisdom about it.
He is fine and he wrote some gems but his political viewpoint is a bunch of poo poo.
Edit: Also, WTF, I am listening and who has a problem with Andy Weir?
-
Heinlein was still pretty liberal for his time, at least as far as authors trying to sell books went. Remember, most of his stuff was right around WW2 and then into the McCarthy era. Imagine trying to dance around socialism when the administration was just itching to put you in jail as an example to the others. And when you get into the 60s and things lightened up, he was right out there, writing the hippie bible, SiaSL.
-
Some people want their Sci fic to be like Asimov all the time. From this point of view, I can see why they wouldn't appreciate Weir.
-
I know some people consider Weir to be an Ernest Cline-esque hack. I can’t comment as I haven’t read any Weir stuff myself.
-
-
27 comments
Because I hate clickbait titles: It's Ayn Rand.
I'd heard so much about Rand and the "genius" of Atlas Shrugged so I sat down read it. The only thing 3 dimensional about the book was when it was closed and sitting on my table.
I'm glad to have read it just so I understand how shallow the arguments are of those that raise it as an ideal to aspire to.
Hell, I assumed, but thank you all the same. Fuck clickbait BS.
You're going god's work