1y ago

Experts slam Trump's lawyer for letting him testify: "Habba did absolutely no good for her client"

www.salon.com

"It's clear Trump wanted to avoid the bloodbath of a cross-examination but wanted to say something"

Former President Donald Trump spent just three minutes on the witness stand Thursday in his defamation trial brought by E. Jean Carroll, using his testimony to declare that he backs his prior deposition denying the writer's claims.

…

As Trump left the courtroom, according to The Messenger's Adam Klasfeld, he complained to the press in the gallery, saying, "It's not America. It's not America. This is not America."

56 comments

This article evaluates her based on her skill as a lawyer, defending her client. That's the job that every other lawyer does. That's not what Trump hired her for, though. Trump knows he will lose this. Her job is to delay the inevitable as much as possible. And she gets a bonus if she manages to get him some platform to air his grievances publically.
This is kind of at odds to the standards of the legal profession, though, and she will probably get disciplined for it. I just hope she was "fake smart" enough to get paid up front.
- I believe it's still called a spore at that size.
- Back in the day, a lot of authentic cowboys headed to Hollywood to work as stuntmen. She's kind of like those cowboys; an actual lawyer playing the role of a lawyer.
  
  You give her way too much credit. I've never taken the bar exam, but, based on having known some very stupid lawyers I am guessing several things:
  There are different levels of difficulty in each state since each state has its own bar exam.
  If you are stupid but have a decent memory, you can pass it because it doesn't require creative thought.
  If you can't even do that, but you've got enough money, you can pay the right people in certain states and "pass" their bar exam.
  Habba is just clearly stupid. I don't know why people are suggesting anything else.
  She even essentially admitted as much.
- But this isn't a criminal case, it's a civil case in the state of New York. Even if Trump wins in November, he will still have to pay up, and wont be able to pardon himself or tell his AG to drop the case. All Habba us doing is pissing off the judge
  
  He's not paying a damn thing himself, it will come out of some SuperPAC. He doesn't care that it's illegal. He already knows nobody can investigate him if he is President, except for Congress, and he just needs 34 Senators willing to keep him away from any consequences of that.
Habba's mission is not to be a good lawyer within the rules and traditions of the courtroom. Habba's mission is to drag the proceedings as much as possible out of the rules of the courtroom, and into the rules of "I'm the leader, do as I say or I'll have you shot."
A lawyer who's staying within the rules of the courtroom is pretty much doomed to failure, and will interfere with mission #2 while they're failing, which is why Trump hates them. Trump is so generally incompetent that it remains to be seen whether mission #2 will be successful. But Trump and Habba are in no way using bad strategy when they try mission #2, because it's certainly possible to win that game, whereas mission #1 is a lost cause at this point.
She’s not trying to be his lawyer. She’s auditioning for the role of his next ex-wife.
"And you say that because you personally made him aware of those confines?" Kaplan said before Trump loudly interrupted to tell his lawyer he "never met this woman." Kaplan then instructed Trump to keep his voice down.
Jesus fucking christ....
Letting him testify
Cute they think that was her decision, let alone her idea to have him rant in the trial. Donnie wanted desperately to speak out in almost every prior case so far, and especially so now we are in primary season to maintain his victim complex
- She's not a competent lawyer by even the most generous of standards. I agree that this was absolutely his idea, but she also has a fiduciary responsibility to her clients, so the blame is certainly hers. He can't actually take the stand unless called by a lawyer, and no competent lawyer would have done that (and some of his other lawyers even prevented him in other cases).
  She's a colossal fuckup, no matter whose hairbrained idea it was initially.
  
  You cannot blame a lawyer for allowing their client to testify, they literally have an ethical obligation to allow a client to testify if the client chooses to (ABA Model Rule 3.3(9) ). You can call her competency into question for other reasons, but she would absolutely be sanctioned if she didn't allow him to testify.
  
  He can't actually take the stand unless called by a lawyer
  While technically true, his lawyer must call him to the stand if he wants it. Lawyers aren’t ethically allowed to silence their own clients’ testimony, even if it is damaging to the case. The lawyer can argue with the client ahead of time and tell them it’s a horrible idea. But if the client refuses to budge and insists, the lawyer has an ethical obligation to call them to the stand. She could literally be cited by the bar association for refusing to let him testify.
  
  And I guess that's the reason why two of his lawyers withdrew, one even the day before trial, because they could not convince him to stay silent and did not want to watch him testify and could not hinder him to testify because of the law.
- Victim complex yes, but I'm also sure he's convinced he could talk his way out of it. He's been able to do that or pay the right people off his whole life so far, and these cases ending poorly for him surely has him convinced that everyone involved is just "doing it wrong" and he needs to step in and fix it himself.
It's not America he is used to, for all these years of golfing, being a showman and conman and hanging out with Epstein and Co with no care for the world around. He could do that until he die, the US of A could've let him. But for whatever reason he went all in.
Your right Donnie it’s not if it was America you would have been held in contempt long ago.
Hey, they let Ted Bundy represent himself because he was obviously better than his legal counsel. He just happened to also be guilty.
- They have to let you represent yourself so long as you're competent to do so, they can assign you a state ordered attorney so things go smoother with filings but it's quite literally a constitutional right.
- So, he and Trump have some things in common. Does Trump own a VW Bug?
"Let him"
You guys would hand Trump a mistrial on a silver platter.
Yeah but were they slammed from like the top rung or just normal slammed?
- Slammed like nineteen ninety eight something something announcer table
  
  God, I miss shittymorph.
The only place you'll find a worse lawyer than Habba is a Simpson's episode.
- Mr. Hutz, do you know you're not wearing any pants?
SLAAAAAAMMMMMM
- AND WELCOME TO THE JAM
"Slam"
Find a better word.
- We have people whose vocabulary consists of "imagine" and "literally" and a jumble of mis-joined words and bad pluralization.
  Imagine u literally backup emails
  This is the hill you're defending?
Habba argued that her arguments for the case's dismissal were being misunderstood, offering to clarify them for the judge. But Kaplan's response was short. “No,” he replied.
He hired some less than excellent bimbo lawyer and it's working out predictably
- Based on the lawsuit against her by a former client, she's an insane backstabbing snake, not a bimbo.
  Her husband was a member at one of Trump's golf courses. She finds out that a waitress at the course was sueing the place and her manager because he had sexually abused her for years and coerced her into it with job threats.
  She befriended the woman, convinced her to drop the actually beneficial lawyer she had, got her to sign an NDA and accept a pittance sum under 20k. Then dropped the woman as a client.
  Allegedly that's how she got the job with Trump. She turned around and went to him and told him what she did and how she saved him millions of dollars.
  However, as I said, the woman is now sueing her and she is facing potentially being disbarred for that evil act.
He's gotta be running out of lawyers willing to take him as a client at this point
- He isn't already?
  
  There's a point there. Ms habbas appears to be what one gets when one has run out of competent lawyers. Without a friendly judge and a good case, the odds of success arent good.
And the judge just allowed it and gave a million warnings and zero consequences

56 comments